RobStenation: Melissa Rosenberg and Peter Facinelli Talk About 'Breaking Dawn' with Showtime

Melissa Rosenberg and Peter Facinelli Talk About 'Breaking Dawn' with Showtime

Twifans

spunk_ransom via @vonch

22 comments:

dina said...: I would gladly La Push her off the cliff. Eclipse is about the triangle?
Have you ever read the damn book woman?; January 12, 2011 6:41 AM
Anonymous said...: MS is all about PR. You can see it in the way she speaks, it's like shoptalk, she knows the tricky words to sell more.
I love Dr. Carlisle and Dr. Cooper. I want to think they're one and the same; January 12, 2011 7:00 AM
Maka said...: Hi!:)

@Dina, agree with your every word.
For me, every "Twilight" book is about Edward and Bella's love. And nothing other.
And esp "Eclipse". When I read it first time, honestly, I couldn't see any triangle. For me, it's about how much E and B love each other, and how strong their love really is.
After all three movies, I really don't trust Mellisa Rosenberg. For Eclipse, my hopes were very high, but I was very disappointed. And I'm very worried about BD.
Anyway, I still keep hoping that BD will be better than Eclipse...

Oh, and btw, I LOVE Peter Facinelli:))

Have a nice day everyone!:)

With love, Maka; January 12, 2011 7:20 AM
Malia said...: Hi Maka & dina! Loves me some PFach bbs...he's the big Dadeh & GrandPapa of them all to me,haha! I agree w/U guys that MR can be such a pain in the "arse",lol...I'm trying to hold on to high hopes f/BD because of BC tho...we shall see...HUGS ALL!!; January 12, 2011 8:26 AM
Anonymous said...: in bd "the passion is less important"???? melissa the story IS the passion!! THAT'S why you suck as screenwriter of this! you don't understand the story!; January 12, 2011 8:28 AM
lala/c said...: well i was following a thread on teitter saome days ago and they were saying that now Summit wants the Jacob book included.hmmmmmm so i guess they do not loose the jacob supporters i take it. what a shame, its true sometimes i too wonder wht books i read.; January 12, 2011 8:39 AM
neelu said...: i will see bd just to see honeymoon scenes.thats it.honestly its edwella which is story is all about.i hate jacob and ness as well.yeah guys i do just because she loves jacob more than her father.; January 12, 2011 9:06 AM
lala/c said...: lol, that was supposed to be twitter.
chicken curry on the menu today!; January 12, 2011 9:24 AM
Malia said...: Haha lala/c...chicken adobo today on my menu bb; My hubs is part Filipino so there ya go...I made beef curry last week; love curry bb; I practically live in that kitchen half the time, so funny tho, I LOVE IT, but eat like a bird; wanna give K my secret recipes; "How To Keep Your Man Loved Up Through His Stomach...& Eating Out Of Your Hands Forever", somehow, I know she doesn't need my help tho, Hahaha, she's SO GOOD!! Hugs Lovees!!; January 12, 2011 10:00 AM
Malia said...: Hey, I forgot...all this talk of chickens make me think of "Feathas"...YES!! ooooooo.......; January 12, 2011 10:02 AM
Anonymous said...: Well I read and seen a couple of interviews with Kristen. She said the script was solid. Peter said a couple of times that it was awesome. I wonder what that means to them exactly. Bill Condon has been doing right by us so far.

Theresa; January 12, 2011 10:39 AM
Maka said...: I totally agree with ya' all. And you know, sometimes I wonder whether or not we read the same book as MS does. I mean, why can't they get that we want to see E/B love story?!

Oh, and now do we have a cooking club, too? lol

With love, Maka; January 12, 2011 10:56 AM
Beside You said...: Agree @ dina and Maka. Jacob at times pisses me off (like Rob talks about in the commentary..
he is a "little prat" at times)in all four books but his friendship is definitely needed.I never saw a love triangle..I saw Jacob lusting for Bella and like Bella says to Jacob..."it's always been him".

I think BD is about E&B:
...marriage,honeymoon,sex,baby,
transformation,Edward's world, &
raising a child together(come on MR say Edward and Bella when you are talking BD..it's NOT just about "growing up" it's about Edward and Bella and their life together as a couple/family). I know I posted about Jacob being integral to the story,and he is but Jacob in BD should definitely be VERY VERY secondary.

And personally, ICK...I am not interested in the background story of the Volturi...I rushed through the Volturi stuff in the book...not my thing...old vampires..old rules.Thanks S as always for the info!

Tha
Tha; January 12, 2011 11:34 AM
lala/c said...: Malia lol, i eat like a pig, should cut down really i used to be slimmer. yep we love curries too yummy.; January 12, 2011 11:35 AM
Misty said...: @Anon8:28 I believe she said the passion IS what's important.

Wow. Such hostility today. I can't believe the actors would feel the same way about Melissa that the fans do. Most of the actors hadn't read the books before they signed on so obviously something in the script attracted them to the project. Melissa has written for a hit TV show and a blockbuster movie franchise. As much as I am disappointed when my favorite scenes or lines are left out, I know I couldn't do any better. So I am reserving judgement regarding Breaking Dawn. I certainly wouldn't want to undertake that convoluted story.; January 12, 2011 12:01 PM
Anonymous said...: Huhh...read that article makes me more like read the book than see the movie! Ahhh...luckily Rob and Kristen are the one reason I see Twilight Saga movies!!! I don't like Jacob's character, he's such a manipulative person...GUG*...GUG*!!!!

rh; January 12, 2011 1:04 PM
Anonymous said...: i really don't like MR..i agree, i think she doesn't understand the story, she still think that jacob is important, but nooooo he isn't, just little part with ness.. E&B are the main part of the book, it's their story!!!we have seen enough jacob..:)
well kristen said the script was good so i will trust her..; January 12, 2011 1:31 PM
Delle1 said...: Actually it's not only MR but SM as well that I blame for the triangle becoming part of the plot of this movie...I feel the same as most of you that there was no triangle in the books but SM seemed to get distracted with her Jacob character and wrote him into more of the story...It's like she forgot about the love in the movies and made it more about Jacob,oh I know that MR wrote the scripts but SM had alot of say about what was scripted...she could've fought for Edward alot harder specially when Bella rides off on the motorcycle with Jacob in front of Edward,never happened in the book and Bella wouldn't have hurt Edwards'feelings like that...sorry for the long post but I get so riled up when I think about how these two have changed the whole feel of the books....; January 12, 2011 2:02 PM
twmmy said...: Oh, yes.All with you I agreed. Specially that, MR AND SM are both the reason of Jacob isvery strong in the films. And yes, we aren't interested in the back-stories, because we've read more better FF-s, than the scripts of the films. I'm just curious - they gon't read the fan-sites at stupid-Summit? Shame on them...
Shme on them to cancel Biel on youtube...; January 12, 2011 4:29 PM
twilightnan said...: Well, I think a lot of regulars commenters are now aware that I'm a very dedicated Edward and Bella supporters since I started blogging in RPL site and moved on here since the site closed down in Sept 2010..To me The Twilight Saga is mainly about "Edward and Bella",it is their lovestory that made me a fan.the other characters are to support the main characters of the story..*EDWARD and BELL *and like the rest of you ,I was not happy with the development of Jacob character..JMO..and I totally agree w/ Delle1..maybe Stephanie Meyer needs reminding that the Twilight books she has written were about..A VAMPIRE Falling IN LOVE WITH A MORTAL GIRL..NOT WEREWOLVES!!..@ Malia you made me hungry now ,going on about that chicken 'ADOBO'..I bet it is yummy!; January 12, 2011 4:29 PM
Anonymous said...: Thanks Misty...I agree wholeheartedly! Also, I'm amazed that anyone would criticize Stephenie Meyer...without her there wouldn't be the wonderful books, the movies, no Rob & Kristen, and this blog wouldn't be about Robstenation. I love the books and the movies and I'm sure it's difficult to fit every nuance in to a two hour time frame, keep Stephenie happy, Summit happy & the fans satisfied as well. I know everyone is entitled to their opinion, but I KNOW Breaking Dawn will be awesome! Keep the faith! Love, Mel from Texas; January 12, 2011 5:52 PM
Misty said...: @MelfromTexas Thanks, Mel. Felt like I was floating an island alone, there.; January 12, 2011 10:50 PM