Stephenie Meyer Discusses Edward's Flaws


Many of you would disagree with Stephenie Meyer’s assessment that the dreamy Edward Cullen has any faults, but Steph says she believes he has flaws. Here is what she said at the fan junket in June. Hear the audio of this discussion at TwiFans

Transcript
TST: With your characters — do they run the show or do you run the show?

SM: This is something I've learned. People think you're crazy when you tell the truth on this question. But, writers don't think you're crazy, because they understand. The characters run the show. Because once you create a character, it's who they are. Sure, there are certain things they can't do. Certain things they can't say; it’s not in character. I had that problem with Edward a lot. In the beginning he was a really, a very strong character. New Moon came about because of his character. I did not want to write him going away, that was not very much fun, but if he hadn’t done that, how could he say he tried everything? He didn't try everything to save her, if he hadn’t gone away. So that whole book revolved around his (Edward's) iron nature that he had, that I could not get around. I could not just make him…he was so loathed to destroy her life. There was no way that he was gonna "okay, you're right. We'll just hang out." He’s also such a know-it-all. Bella's trying to tell him "look, this is something different than we think it is" and he's "no, I know better....I'm a 110." He's kind-of a brat sometimes. It’s so funny when people think I have constructed (in a negative way) my idea of the perfect man and how flawless he is. No, he's very flawed. I'm well aware of that. And he's lived in this world where rules don't apply to him. He does stuff that is over the line for a human person. But he is a vampire and can fool a lot of people. So going into someone's room at night isn't that bad, in comparison. And the rules don't apply to him; he does all kinds of really shallow stuff. But I still like him.

via team-twilight

11 comments:

lala/c said...

i do not know what the hell she means,a brat? what about Jacob then?
i keep saying this,maybe i read a different book.lol
thats how they made Edward look in Eclipse,but the book def was not like that.oh maybe she is trying to justify the FlAWS OF THE SCRIPT!

KPattz said...

Nobody says that Edward is a flawless person.He's a bit of selfish,stubborn,but brat and swallow?Does she even know her creation?I'm sure no.Edward is far away from swallow.I think Mrs Meyer needs to re-read her books, and get over the "i'm gonna push Jacob so much by tearing Edward apart"thing,because IT'S.NEVER.GONNA.HAPPEN.She tried it with BD and all the fandom rejected it.She made Edward a supporting role and gave Jacob a whole book.

lala/c said...

oh good KPattz i am glad others see it the way i do.at first i used to think that i did not get the book or something.
they are still getting married in breaking Dawn right? lol
you never now,we might get a different perspective.lol

Maka said...

Agree with you KPattz and Lala. Seriously, is she really talking about Edward??? It really makes me angry. I'm really glad that here are the people who think the way I do...
With love, Maka

RobStenation said...

Again guys, I don't approve comments with links bec I cant view(nor copy to view) the URL during moderation.

KPattz said...

@Shaui,sorry about my comment with the link.I didn't know that you can't see the URL.It was a funny link,though.It was Edward's review on BD.Hilarious!

Anonymous said...

All characters have flaws, that's whats makes them so interesting!

I have to agree that Edward is NOT a brat, but he is a perfectionist, he is protective...that's what makes him so lovable.

PrettySparklies said...

Yay! I also thought I was alone in not thinking Edward is a bad guy. He's just protecting her because she has the worst luck in the world and he's madly in love with her. I seriously believe that Bella was born to be a vampire/with Edward. All signs point to yes. :D
I love you guys and this site! :D

RobStenation said...

I love Edward. Period. Flaws and all. If you can call his immense love for Bella a flaw, then ok. haha

ElizabethMC said...

Edward is ideal because he is self-aware of his own imperfections. He is not how SM describes him which is so inappropriate. Midnight Sun allows us to understand what is behind his dazzling eyes. SM tests my patience but she is still his almighty creator.

deanie said...

we are seeing Edward through Bellas eyes that is why we do not care to see the flaws. he is perfect! I think we feel that way about Rob also. SM relates to Edward character so maybe she sees herself in him?.I hope to read Midnight Sun soon. have a great day chicas.PS Shaui hope you're feeling better